Sound Delay

Hopefully it’s just me, but their seems to be a delay in the sound system. Anyone else seen this?

I’ve got a simple 2D app with a bouncing ball (tweak of # 27 sample). When it hit’s the floor it should beep. What I’m seeing is it bouncing about 1/4± up the screen till the sound is made (more noticed on the first bounce). I’ve tried a few different ways to make sound, preloading, .wav vs .ogg, etc., and nothing seems to mater much.

Played with sample #29 a bit via taking setting down to the bottom 0.01, and then when the tone starts to move hit the up key. The delay seems to be evident to me there also.

Seemed to be evident in a 3D example I tried also, but it’s harder to tell there (imaging is more distracting).

All these tests are somewhat subjective so would like any feedback. I’ve tried a few different environments and it seems to be evident in all of them (Android being the worse).

I’m stuck at this point.

You could try to control the engine’s startup parameters for smaller sound buffer size. On the default setting it’s on purpose conservatively large to avoid glitches / dropouts. However it may not help all the way - in this regard Urho is at the mercy of SDL, which in turn is at the mercy of the operating system. Android especially is notorious with its audio latency.

You may also want to find our more about recent audio API improvement in SDL 2.0.4. I have quoted relevant bullet points from WhatsNew.txt below

[quote]* Added an API to queue audio instead of using the audio callback: SDL_QueueAudio(), SDL_GetQueuedAudioSize(), SDL_ClearQueuedAudio()

  • Added events for audio device hot plug support: SDL_AUDIODEVICEADDED, SDL_AUDIODEVICEREMOVED[/quote]
    The SDL-2.0.4-upgrade branch should be merged into master branch shortly. Having said that, Urho3D game engine has not taken advantage of this new API yet. So, you will have to experiment with it yourself and if it works then probably you can submit your changes back as PR. Probably we should have audio mode enumeration declaration to support both callback and queue audio.

If I understand right how it works like, the queue audio mode can have its own drawbacks; I remember the original Quake working in such manner (instead of IRQ driven playback), and it would get dropouts or audio buffer repeats when the FPS was low.

I have not experiment with the new queue API myself but from the SDL wiki: wiki.libsdl.org/SDL_QueueAudio then I reckon when the audio buffer is under-run then it will just play silence. I think there is nothing we could do about it in such cases.

Yeah, I believe it would be fine as an option. There would be quite minimal changes to Audio; in queue mode it would listen to a per-frame event and push a suitable amount of audio each frame from the main thread. This is btw. safer since there are no potential threading issues like with the audio callback.

Thanks for giving this some consideration. Looks like there may be some improvement to be had with 2.0.4. Doesn?t sound like a quick fix though (especially for me).

Thanks!

I played with sound recently. I think it works just right.

How big is your music file?

Do you use Audacity? Try to remove any delay at the beginning of the music file.

Regards

George, you must have a really fast machine! I decided to run some further tests with a somewhat stripped version of the code I’ve been playing with and it is still apparent to me.

Interestingly, I created a quick bouncy ball app using Unity on a Virtual Machine to compare (amplifies issues like this) and the issue was Not there with Unity. The differences between Unity and Urho3D in this regard is black/white apparent to me on the VM (more subjective on my i7 main environment).

Here’s the code I’ve used, should anyone want to look at it. I’d be happy to find out I was doing something stupid here!

[code]// CyBall.h

//#define ANDROID_TEST true //screen diffs. Android fonts display about 1/2 size also, so may need to 2x those.

#ifndef _CYBALL_H
#define _CYBALL_H

#include <Urho3D/Engine/Application.h>
#include <Urho3D/Engine/Engine.h>
#include <Urho3D/Graphics/Graphics.h>
#include <Urho3D/Input/Input.h>
#include <Urho3D/Input/InputEvents.h>
#include <Urho3D/Resource/ResourceCache.h>
#include <Urho3D/UI/UI.h>
#include <Urho3D/UI/Text.h>
#include <Urho3D/UI/Font.h>
#include <Urho3D/IO/Log.h>

#include <Urho3D/Scene/Scene.h>
#include <Urho3D/Scene/SceneEvents.h>
#include <Urho3D/Graphics/Octree.h>
#include <Urho3D/Graphics/Camera.h>
#include <Urho3D/Graphics/RenderPath.h>
#include <Urho3D/Graphics/Renderer.h>
#include <Urho3D/Graphics/DebugRenderer.h>
#include <Urho3D/Core/Timer.h> //for randomizer

#include <Urho3D/Core/CoreEvents.h> //E_UPDATE
#include <Urho3D/Graphics/GraphicsEvents.h> //E_SCREENMODE

#include <Urho3D/Urho2D/CollisionBox2D.h>
#include <Urho3D/Urho2D/CollisionCircle2D.h>
#include <Urho3D/Urho2D/Drawable2D.h>
#include <Urho3D/Urho2D/PhysicsWorld2D.h>
#include <Urho3D/Urho2D/RigidBody2D.h>
#include <Urho3D/Urho2D/Sprite2D.h>
#include <Urho3D/Urho2D/StaticSprite2D.h>

#include <Urho3D/Audio/Sound.h>
#include <Urho3D/Audio/SoundSource3D.h>

#include <Urho3D/Urho2D/PhysicsEvents2D.h>

#include <Urho3D/Physics/CollisionShape.h>
#include <Urho3D/Physics/PhysicsWorld.h>
#include <Urho3D/Physics/RigidBody.h>
#include <Urho3D/Physics/Constraint.h>

using namespace Urho3D;

class CyBall : public Application
{

URHO3D_OBJECT(CyBall,Application);

public:
CyBall(Context* context);

virtual void Setup();
virtual void Start();
virtual void Stop();

Graphics* graphics;
ResourceCache* cache;

bool drawDebug_;	//testing render

float r_width_, p_width_; //rendering / display(game screen pix) window size as floats
float r_height_, p_height_;
float x_scale_, y_scale_, s_scale_;	//x, y, and min(x,y) ratio scale for position and resonable size's
float pad_psizeH2_;		//1/2 paddle in pix after scaled

// min/max movment of paddel on screen, in pix
float pad_VposMax_;
float pad_VposMin_;

float pad_Hsizefactor_;	//make it wider (todo: through UI)

SharedPtr<Scene> scene_;
Node* cameraNode_;
Camera* camera_;

// play area frame sprites
Node* BottomFrame_;
Node* TopFrame_;
Node* LeftFrame_;
Node* RightFrame_;

Node* paddle_;
Node* ball_;

//global sounds
Node* sound_hit_Node_;
SoundSource* sound_source_;
SharedPtr<Sound> sound_;


void HandleKeyDown(StringHash eventType,VariantMap& eventData);
void HandleUpdate(StringHash eventType,VariantMap& eventData);
void HandleScreenMode(StringHash eventType, VariantMap& eventData);
void HandlePostRenderUpdate(StringHash eventType, VariantMap& eventData);
void HandleCollision(StringHash eventType, VariantMap& eventData);

void PlayMySound(String soundFileName);

private:
float PAD_PSIZEV;
float PAD_PSIZEH;
float PAD_PSIZEH2;

void CreateScene();
void SetupViewport();
void ScaleScreen();
void DropTarget();

};

#endif // #ifndef _CYBALL_H[/code]

[code]#include “CyBall.h”

using namespace Urho3D;

CyBall :: CyBall(Context* context) : Application(context)
{ //full application global stuff

}

void CyBall::Setup()
{ // Called before engine initialization. engineParameters_ member variable can be modified here
drawDebug_ = false;

engineParameters_["WindowTitle"] = "SoundDelay";
engineParameters_["FullScreen"] = false;

engineParameters_["WindowWidth"] = 900;
engineParameters_["WindowHeight"] = 720;
engineParameters_["WindowResizable"] = true;
engineParameters_["PauseMinimized"] = true;

engineParameters_["MaxFps"] = 60;

//inital set some things as origonal constants..
PAD_PSIZEV = 0.16f;	//real(or expected) size of sprite - Vertical;
PAD_PSIZEH = 0.32f;	//real(or expected) size of sprite - Horz.;
PAD_PSIZEH2 = 0.16f;	//1/2 real(or expected) size of sprite - Horz.;

//set some things to test for..
scene_ = NULL;
ball_ = NULL;

//init setups
pad_Hsizefactor_ = 2;

}

void CyBall::Start()
{

cache = GetSubsystem<ResourceCache>();
graphics = GetSubsystem<Graphics>();


//get rendering window size as floats
r_width_ = (float)graphics->GetWidth();
r_height_ = (float)graphics->GetHeight();
p_width_ = r_width_ * PIXEL_SIZE;
p_height_ = r_height_ * PIXEL_SIZE;

// Called after engine initialization. Setup application & subscribe to events here
SubscribeToEvent(E_KEYDOWN, URHO3D_HANDLER(CyBall, HandleKeyDown));
SubscribeToEvent(E_UPDATE, URHO3D_HANDLER(CyBall, HandleUpdate));

SubscribeToEvent(E_SCREENMODE, URHO3D_HANDLER(CyBall, HandleScreenMode));
SubscribeToEvent(E_POSTRENDERUPDATE, URHO3D_HANDLER(CyBall, HandlePostRenderUpdate));	//debug geometry

SubscribeToEvent(E_PHYSICSBEGINCONTACT2D, URHO3D_HANDLER(CyBall, HandleCollision));

GetSubsystem<Input>()->SetMouseVisible(false);
GetSubsystem<Input>()->SetMouseGrabbed(true);

CreateScene();
SetupViewport();
DropTarget();

}

void CyBall::Stop()
{
// Perform optional cleanup after main loop has terminated
}

void CyBall::HandleCollision(StringHash eventType, VariantMap& eventData)
{
PlayMySound(“Ding1.wav”);
}

/* Just Sprints in 2D /
void CyBall::HandlePostRenderUpdate(StringHash eventType, VariantMap& eventData)
{
// If draw debug mode is enabled, draw viewport debug geometry. This time use depth test, as otherwise the result becomes
// hard to interpret due to large object count
if (drawDebug_) {
PhysicsWorld2D
physicsWorld = scene_->GetComponent();
physicsWorld->DrawDebugGeometry();
}
}

void CyBall::HandleKeyDown(StringHash eventType, VariantMap& eventData)
{
using namespace KeyDown;
// Check for pressing ESC. Note the engine_ member variable for convenience access to the Engine object
int key = eventData[P_KEY].GetInt();

// Toggle debug geometry with space
if (key == (KEY_SPACE))
	drawDebug_ = !drawDebug_;

else if (key == KEY_TAB)
//else if (key == KEY_ESC)
{
    GetSubsystem<Input>()->SetMouseVisible(!GetSubsystem<Input>()->IsMouseVisible());
    GetSubsystem<Input>()->SetMouseGrabbed(!GetSubsystem<Input>()->IsMouseGrabbed());
	PlayMySound("Ding1.wav");
}
else if (key == KEY_ESC)
	engine_->Exit();
else if (key == KEY_P)
	scene_->SetUpdateEnabled(!scene_->IsUpdateEnabled());

}

// Hit each frame.
void CyBall::HandleUpdate(StringHash eventType, VariantMap& eventData)
{
float timeStep=eventData[Update::P_TIMESTEP].GetFloat(); //Current frame timestep as seconds.
// Movement speed as world units per second
float MOVE_SPEED=10.0f;
// Mouse sensitivity as degrees per pixel
float MOUSE_SENSITIVITY = 0.01f;

// camera movement
Input* input=GetSubsystem<Input>();

//need to do these key's here since we need timeStep
// TO DO: faster while key is held down.
if (input->GetKeyDown('W'))
{
	Vector2 oldpostion = paddle_->GetPosition2D();
	oldpostion.y_ += (MOVE_SPEED * timeStep);
	if (oldpostion.y_ > pad_VposMax_) oldpostion.y_ = pad_VposMax_;
	paddle_->SetPosition2D(oldpostion);
}
if (input->GetKeyDown('S'))
{
	Vector2 oldpostion = paddle_->GetPosition2D();
	oldpostion.y_ -= (MOVE_SPEED * timeStep);
	if (oldpostion.y_ < pad_VposMin_) oldpostion.y_ = pad_VposMin_;
	paddle_->SetPosition2D(oldpostion);
}
else if(input->GetKeyDown('A'))
{
	Vector2 oldpostion = paddle_->GetPosition2D();
	oldpostion.x_ -= (MOVE_SPEED * timeStep);
	if (oldpostion.x_ < pad_psizeH2_) oldpostion.x_ = pad_psizeH2_;
	paddle_->SetPosition2D(oldpostion);
}
else if (input->GetKeyDown('D'))
{
	Vector2 oldpostion = paddle_->GetPosition2D();
	oldpostion.x_ += (MOVE_SPEED * timeStep);
	if (oldpostion.x_ > p_width_ - pad_psizeH2_) oldpostion.x_ = p_width_ - pad_psizeH2_;
	paddle_->SetPosition2D(oldpostion);
}

// do Mouse stuff...
if (!GetSubsystem<Input>()->IsMouseVisible())
{
	IntVector2 mouseMove = input->GetMouseMove() ;

	// handle mouse paddle movment
	if ((mouseMove.x_!= 0 && mouseMove.x_>-2000000000) || (mouseMove.y_ != 0 && mouseMove.y_>-2000000000))
	{
		Vector2 oldpostion = paddle_->GetPosition2D();

		// Horz movement
		oldpostion.x_ += (MOUSE_SENSITIVITY*mouseMove.x_);
		if (oldpostion.x_ < pad_psizeH2_) oldpostion.x_ = pad_psizeH2_;
		if (oldpostion.x_ > p_width_ - pad_psizeH2_) oldpostion.x_ = p_width_ - pad_psizeH2_;

		// Vert Movement
		oldpostion.y_ -= (MOUSE_SENSITIVITY*mouseMove.y_);
		if (oldpostion.y_ < pad_VposMin_) oldpostion.y_ = pad_VposMin_;
		if (oldpostion.y_ > pad_VposMax_) oldpostion.y_ = pad_VposMax_;

		paddle_->SetPosition2D(oldpostion);
	}
}

}

void CyBall::HandleScreenMode(StringHash eventType, VariantMap& eventData)
{
//get rendering window size as floats
float new_r_width_ = (float)graphics->GetWidth();
float new_r_height_ = (float)graphics->GetHeight();

if (new_r_width_ != r_width_ || new_r_height_ != r_height_)
{
	if (new_r_width_ < 300 || new_r_height_ < 300) {
		new_r_width_ = ( new_r_width_ < 300 ? 300 : new_r_width_ );
		new_r_height_ = (new_r_height_ < 300 ? 300 : new_r_height_);
		graphics->SetMode((int)new_r_width_, (int)new_r_height_);
	}

	//screen size changed.
	r_width_ = new_r_width_;
	r_height_ = new_r_height_;

	p_width_ = r_width_ * PIXEL_SIZE;
	p_height_ = r_height_ * PIXEL_SIZE;

	ScaleScreen();
}

}

void CyBall::ScaleScreen()
{

cameraNode_->SetPosition(Vector3(p_width_/2, p_height_/2, -10.0f));
camera_->SetOrthoSize(Vector2(p_width_, p_height_));

x_scale_ = 1.2f * (r_width_ / 1280.0f);
y_scale_ = 1.2f * (r_height_ / 800.0f);
s_scale_ = Min(x_scale_, y_scale_);

//x_scale_ = y_scale_ = s_scale_ = 1;

//position these at center, scale outward
BottomFrame_->SetPosition(Vector3(p_width_/2, 0.0f, 0.0f));
BottomFrame_->SetScale(Vector3((r_width_/32), 0.24f, 0.0f));

TopFrame_->SetPosition(Vector3(p_width_ / 2, p_height_ , 0.0f));
TopFrame_->SetScale(Vector3((r_width_ / 32), 0.24f, 0.0f));

LeftFrame_->SetPosition(Vector3(0.0f, p_height_ / 2, 0.0f));
LeftFrame_->SetScale(Vector3(0.24f, (r_height_ / 32) ,  0.0f));

RightFrame_->SetPosition(Vector3(p_width_, p_height_/2, 0.0f));
RightFrame_->SetScale(Vector3(0.24f, (r_height_ / 32), 0.0f));

// Vertical postion limits
pad_VposMin_ = ((PAD_PSIZEV / 2)  * y_scale_) + 0.05f;	//offset a little above ground
pad_VposMax_ = ((PAD_PSIZEV / 2)  * y_scale_) + (p_height_ * 0.25f);	//bottom 1/4 of scren

paddle_->SetPosition(Vector3(p_width_ / 2, pad_VposMin_, 0.0f));
paddle_->SetScale2D(Vector2(x_scale_ * pad_Hsizefactor_, PAD_PSIZEV * y_scale_));
pad_psizeH2_ = PAD_PSIZEH2 * x_scale_ * pad_Hsizefactor_;

if(ball_ != NULL)
	ball_->SetScale2D(s_scale_, s_scale_);

}

void CyBall::DropTarget()
{
ball_ = scene_->CreateChild(“Ball”);
ball_->SetPosition(Vector3((p_width_ / 2), (p_height_ - 0.32f) , 0.0f));

// Create rigid body
RigidBody2D* body = ball_->CreateComponent<RigidBody2D>();
body->SetBodyType(BT_DYNAMIC);
body->SetLinearDamping(0.0f);
body->SetAngularDamping(0.0f);

StaticSprite2D* staticSprite = ball_->CreateComponent<StaticSprite2D>();
Sprite2D* ballSprite = cache->GetResource<Sprite2D>("Urho2D/Ball.png");
staticSprite->SetSprite(ballSprite);


// Create circle collistion shape
CollisionCircle2D* shape = ball_->CreateComponent<CollisionCircle2D>();
shape->SetRadius(0.16f);	// Set radius	//1/2 of 32bit sprint
shape->SetDensity(0.20f);	// Set shape density (kilograms per meter squared) Effects rolling, etc.
shape->SetFriction(0.5f);	// Set friction.
shape->SetRestitution(0.990f);	// Set restitution: bounce factor	// <1 smaller = less bounce, >1 additive bounce to infinity

ball_->SetScale2D(Vector2(s_scale_, s_scale_));

}

void CyBall::CreateScene()
{
if(scene_ != NULL) {
return;
}
scene_ = new Scene(context_);
scene_->CreateComponent();
scene_->CreateComponent();//for debugging
scene_->CreateComponent(); //for debugging

// Create camera node
cameraNode_ = scene_->CreateChild("Camera");
camera_ = cameraNode_->CreateComponent<Camera>();
camera_->SetOrthographic(true);

// Create 2D physics world component
scene_->CreateComponent<PhysicsWorld2D>();

Sprite2D* boxSprite = cache->GetResource<Sprite2D>("Urho2D/Box.png");
Sprite2D* ballSprite = cache->GetResource<Sprite2D>("Urho2D/Ball.png");
Sprite2D* paddleSprite = cache->GetResource<Sprite2D>("Urho2D/Box.png");

// Create frame bixground.
BottomFrame_= scene_->CreateChild("FrameB");
TopFrame_ = scene_->CreateChild("FrameT");
LeftFrame_ = scene_->CreateChild("FrameL");
RightFrame_ = scene_->CreateChild("FrameR");
// Create 2D rigid body for gound
BottomFrame_->CreateComponent<RigidBody2D>();
TopFrame_->CreateComponent<RigidBody2D>();
LeftFrame_->CreateComponent<RigidBody2D>();
RightFrame_->CreateComponent<RigidBody2D>();

StaticSprite2D* FrameSprite = BottomFrame_->CreateComponent<StaticSprite2D>();
FrameSprite->SetSprite(boxSprite);
FrameSprite->SetLayer(5);	// in front of Paddle

FrameSprite = TopFrame_->CreateComponent<StaticSprite2D>();
FrameSprite->SetSprite(boxSprite);
FrameSprite = LeftFrame_->CreateComponent<StaticSprite2D>();
FrameSprite->SetSprite(boxSprite);
FrameSprite = RightFrame_->CreateComponent<StaticSprite2D>();
FrameSprite->SetSprite(boxSprite);

// Create box collider for Frame
CollisionBox2D* groundShape = BottomFrame_->CreateComponent<CollisionBox2D>();
groundShape->SetSize(Vector2(0.32f, 0.32f));
groundShape->SetFriction(0.5f);

groundShape = TopFrame_->CreateComponent<CollisionBox2D>();
groundShape->SetSize(Vector2(0.32f, 0.32f));
groundShape->SetFriction(0.5f);

groundShape = LeftFrame_->CreateComponent<CollisionBox2D>();
groundShape->SetSize(Vector2(0.32f, 0.32f));
groundShape->SetFriction(0.5f);

groundShape = RightFrame_->CreateComponent<CollisionBox2D>();
groundShape->SetSize(Vector2(0.32f, 0.32f));
groundShape->SetFriction(0.5f);

paddle_ = scene_->CreateChild("Paddle");
// Create rigid body
paddle_->CreateComponent<RigidBody2D>();
paddle_->GetComponent<RigidBody2D>()->SetBodyType(BT_STATIC);

FrameSprite = paddle_->CreateComponent<StaticSprite2D>();
FrameSprite->SetSprite(paddleSprite);
groundShape = paddle_->CreateComponent<CollisionBox2D>();
groundShape->SetSize(Vector2(PAD_PSIZEH, PAD_PSIZEV));

FrameSprite->SetLayer(1);

ScaleScreen();

//some sound setup...
sound_hit_Node_ = scene_->CreateChild("HitSound");
sound_source_ = sound_hit_Node_->CreateComponent<SoundSource>();
sound_source_->SetSoundType(SOUND_EFFECT);

sound_ = cache->GetResource<Sound>("Ding1.wav");

}

void CyBall::PlayMySound(String soundFileName)
{
//some sound setup…
//sound_hit_Node_ = scene_->CreateChild(“HitSound”);
//sound_source_ = sound_hit_Node_->CreateComponent();
//sound_source_->SetSoundType(SOUND_EFFECT);

//ignore what's passed in for now. JUST PLAY THE DING...
//sound_ = cache->GetResource<Sound>(soundFileName);
sound_source_->Play(sound_);

}

void CyBall::SetupViewport()
{
Renderer* renderer = GetSubsystem();

// Set up a viewport to the Renderer subsystem so that the 3D scene can be seen
SharedPtr<Viewport> viewport(new Viewport(context_, scene_, cameraNode_->GetComponent<Camera>()));
renderer->SetViewport(0, viewport);

}

URHO3D_DEFINE_APPLICATION_MAIN(CyBall)[/code]

You’ll have to add a sound beep file of your choosing, called “Ding1.wav”.

Finally got around to trying the startup params in a more controlled setting.

Set the SoundBuffer down to 10, and it helped a lot. Probably at least a 50% improvement in response in my various windows environments. Haven?t tried Android yet (it was unusable before), but would think it would help.

Not sure how this might effect a busy sound system down the road (can’t think it’s all good)? None of the other sound settings had any noticeable effect.

Thanks for the feedback.